Wednesday 6 January 2010

That evening, I almost killed myself



Here’s my fifth standard report card. Check out the phenomenally poor marks and the hurtful comments from teachers. That evening, as I was walking back home, I was convinced of being a hopeless loser, that I had badly let my parents down, and that I must simply kill myself. And as fate would have it, when I returned home, they were showing the film ‘Anand’ on Doordarshan, which I sat and watched. And got even more depressed.

Just then my dad returned from work, and asked me why I was looking so glum. Anyways having given up on life (so what further harm could dad’s pasting do??), I showed him this report card. And his reaction was shocking! He patted me on the back, gave me some money, and said, “Don’t worry beta, all’s not lost. Just keep working at it and am sure things will improve. And even if they don’t, not to worry, I am always there for you. Now go and buy your friends some ice cream and have fun. Just take the evening off and don’t think about it for now.”

That totally unexpected reaction from my dad knocked my socks off, it changed my life. Instead of feeling depressed, I began to feel a sense of self-confidence, a fierce determination to work harder. The next day I asked my dad to get me a private tutor, which he did. And I used that tutor to teach me just one thing: how I could memorise my study material. That the tutor did happily, and he taught me tricks on blindly ratofying my syllabus.

And here’s what happened: I began to mug every subject, without even attempting to understand the matter, and lo and behold! From the sixth standard onward I was amongst the top six rankers, year on year. What this tells us about our education system is just one thing: IT SUCKS! The entire exercise is designed to guage your parroting skills, and that’s it. The teachers gave a rat’s arse whether we really comprehended the subjects. But that’s not the topic of my discussion.

What I want to say is this: That evening if my dad had spanked me, put me under pressure, and said I would never make it in life, I would surely have been dead.

Here’s the deal: I think it’s absolutely silly to blame movies, television programmes, teachers, social pressures and the like for child suicides. At best they can add on to a child’s frustrations, but are never the root cause. The key issue is and has always been: bad parenting. I think parents are mainly responsible when kids take their own lives. I know of parents who put immense emotional pressure: “I have always dreamed of a doctor in our family, my hopes are pinned on you, son.” “You will become a clerk and rot your whole life if you don’t get admission into that MBA school.” “Look at Sharma’s daughter, she’s so smart and talented. Learn something from her, you fool!” And so on. In fact, here’s a great example: We were once shooting an ad film at the Film City. One lad had been chosen to play a minor role in that advert. Now, the poor thing got nervy, and just wouldn’t deliver. The boy’s mom grabbed the child and beat him mercilessly, fearing that her son would lose this assignment. And this made matters even worse. Anyway, the director asked for the mother to be thrown out of the sets, and he himself handled the child. By telling him silly jokes and bantering with him, he could get the boy into a cheerful mood and the film was shot. And yet, as soon as the mom arrived, she again began tormenting the poor kid!

Unfortunately, after the child dies, none of this comes to light. One, because the last thing cops would want to do is harass grieving parents. And two, even if they did, this sort of stuff is impossible to prove. And so, the tragedy keeps happening.

All those middle-class parents reading this, please take note: Quite often, unwittingly, it’s possible you are driving your child to breakpoint. By loading them with unreal expectations, or by hoping that they would one day realise your own unrealised dreams. Or by simply worrying about their future, not understanding that often some kids bloom late in life. Or find their calling late in life.

Now, admittedly, neither am I a child psychologist nor a parent. However, I did want to share my dad’s attitude in the face of a very poor report card of his son. Maybe we can all learn something from that. My dad is no more, but this one lesson he taught me, will stay with me for life.

And yeah, go ahead and snigger at my report card. I am doing ditto!! Haha.

31 comments:

Sugar & Spice said...

i totally agree.. though i was always a good student... i never topped.. maybe if i had been a muggoo, i may have... but i spent time instead with family friends, extra currics, hobbies etc... was always a smart worker, not a hard worker... and my parents were ok with that. mine was prolly the only house where teh cable connection was not cut, or kids were not grounded for a month during exams... my dad's an MBBS from AIIMS, mom's graduated from a top DU college, but never did they tell me i have to be a doc or engr or whatever. i still managed to get into IIM Ahmedabad, and tho im not a banker in USA earning millions of $$, im happy being where i am :))

ofcourse things were not so easy for my bro... he was an average student and prolly spent his wjhole life being compared to his elder sis. he was shy and dint participate much in extra currics etc. after managing to pass school, he thought of doing CA, gave up after first set of exams cuz his heart was set on animation. he even tried doin a correspondence course, but realised he cd not pull it off. finally he did a diploma in animation and is now working on a much hyped hindi animation movie with top stars... he may not be earning millions, but he is happy doing what he loves.

though compared to me (80-90% in school, univ topper in BA Eco, IIMA), he did not go teh traditional path and get 100% in everything, but my parents never raised a finger and made him feel like he is any less than me. they are equally proud of their animator son, as they are of their MBA daughter.

I thank god every day for such parents! though no one i know has committed suicide, i knwo enough people who are vurdened by the weight of their parents expectations, and many are into depression.

I was really happy to see taare zameen par, and bits of 3 idiots, which addressed this major flaw with our edu system, this race to come firts without caring about actual development, and the family pressure.

i hope with time indian parents and education system both understand this and work towards making a more wholesome learning system!!

suchitra said...

U r lucky to have a father like tht.i hope to be the same with my kid. like i wrote yde on FB,todays parents r a changed lot and r nt behind marks but total growth of child .Still its more difficult to maintain a balance between be a mother and a frnd to yr child.u may find it silly,aftr readng the suicide reports,i actually fasted yde as a penance for fightng with my 12 yr old son on sunde over his studies.

Chandrima said...

I am also thankful to my father for not pressurizing me to join engineering or medical like all my peers...in fact so that I would not have to join these 2 streams I joined Arts..whereas I used to be a topper in Science...but thanks to him...I never felt the guilty about it (though my Mom is still not happy about it)..but I don't care...I got to do... See More what I wanted to do ultimately...it feels so worthless a cause when I hear about Suicides due to marks/studies etc...the system should hold the parents responsible only..jail them whether they grieve or not!!

Roli said...

same here...i was always above average in studies. Drifted from electrical engg to software testing and have finally found my calling - writing. but throughout, thankfully, my parents stood by me in whatever I wanted to do...no pressure, no negativity...nothing!

Anil T said...

Aditi: thanks for sharing. Glad you had such supportive parents. But many aren't so lucky. And yes, we need a holistic approach to education out here. Rgrds.

Unknown said...

hey anil!!!!
gr8!!!! seems u ve snatched the words from my mouth n d thoughts from my mind......i completely agree with you. Its silly to blame movies for child suicides, but again, on second thoughts, I feel media is to be blamed for this. Instead of giving coverage to such news just for the sake of sensation and creating hullabaloo media should promote a beautiful message this awesome movie has given "do not run behind success......try to be capable.....and success will run behind you!!!!!!wishing u n ur family "aal well" and a lot of happiness in 2010.......

Freddy said...

Beautifully written as always!

Warmest, F

Sajida said...

Hi Anil,



It’s been a long time…..I do read your blogs sometimes and thanks for sharing this one.



My husband and I are firm believers that there are no problem children only problem parents!



Regards,

Sajida

rohan said...

Hi Anil,

coincidentally i happened to find my Sr. kg marksheet by chance yesterday. I must say i did a lot better than you:) and it did bring fond memories of school. I have to admit that having seen my classmates literally go through their 'lifecycle' i am convinced that academics, and especailly early academics, has little say on wot you turn out to be in life. The late bloomers from school turned out the most successful both academically and professionally in 'engineering' and 'medical' fields. The traditionally-non-inclined like us did quite well in life too despite studying in ssc/hSc (and not ICSE/CBSE), not topping anything, just about scraping thru college, not knowing where life was headed but still made a successful space for ourselves. And believe me i know loads of the 'u-will -not-be-good-for-anything' types that are well settled and happy too..Which is the reason i shun peopl who tell me to put my 'one and half year old kid' in pre-school( she will develop better and socialise early in life they say..i am suprised wot marketing bullshit can do..). I am convinced i will send her to ssc and not icse and not bother if she stands first or last in class (as long as she gets a good education) and encourage her to pursue her tastes and hobbies. I only pray that i dont fall prey to herd mentality. I always tell people who give me advice on my kid to back off - i didnt turn out too bad you see...Pls let the kids be...

Dr.P.V.Vaidyanathan said...

Hi, Anil, I'm a child specilist from Mumbai, and have a lot of childhood stress. In fact, bcos of the amount of stress that I saw, I actually sat down and wrote a book titled Make Your Child Stress Free, in 2007. Whatever you have said makes complete sense, and is one of the most sensible pieces that I have read about child psychology, in a long time. It would be a pleasure to share my book with you. Kindly let me know where I can send a copy.

In my opinion, many children are born with a potential for depression and suicide. If they don't find the right triggers, they will carry on, till they become adults. But given the right triggers----educational pressures, parental expectations, improper food and sleep, media hype, body image hype, peer pressure, non-availablity of parents etc, they might take the ultimate step. We can only hope to reduce or eliminate these triggers, to avoid this. But in my opinion, all parents will say "Yes, but you know, what you say is true, but still, academics is everything in this country and children must work hard blah, blah, blah.... Acceptance and understanding are very major issues here, often coming only after the child has done something stupid.

Anil T said...

Rohan,
Absolutely! This herd mentality sucks. Every parent has to bring up their children in their own way. No two kids are the same! Best wishes.
Anil

Anil T said...

Dear Dr.P.V.Vaidyanathan,
Thanks for writing in. You have made some really insightful observations. Will share with others too. Do let me know the title of your book, will get hold of it from a book store.
Many thanks and regards
Anil

Dr.P.V.Vaidyanathan said...

Anil, the title of the book is MAKE YOUR CHILD STRESS FREE. It is published by Ameya Prakashan, Pune, and should be available at Crossword/Landmark/Oddessy etc. If you cant find it, don't hesitate to let me know and I shall courier a copy across.

Anil T said...

will do, doc. many thanks!
regards
anil

SHINY said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Hi Anil,
Maybe to an extent your views are correct. But this is not the case always. Sometimes, some kids are just impossible to deal with. Most kids have normal intelligence required to clear our type of exams. But they want to do everything but study. Are parents wrong in correcting them? No. If a child is going wrong, the parents have to see that he is brought to the right track. Every parent wishes to see his/her child do well in life and acts in the best interest of the child. We all received a spanking now and then. But rarely did we think of suicide as an answer. Things have changed now. It is all happenning because now children know "their rights but not their responsibilities". Such acts I feel are an outcome to 'teach the parents a lesson'. A way to escape it all. Not fair to the parents. They deserve better.
Minal Mhatre,
Thane

Anil T said...

Hi Minal,
You have a point there. Parents can't simply do nothing when the kids don't pay attention to their careers. However, I suspect its gotta be a mix of affection, assertiveness and encouragement. And also, compassion. The kids must never be made to feel like they are losers. Simply using high pressure on them to score at all costs can be counter productive.
Thanks for yr views, do appreciate.
Regards
Anil

Unknown said...

Hi Anil Just wanted you to know that it is a vicious cycle too, teachers put pressure on the kids and parents bcoz the kid is not scoring 80's and 90's so he is not a "good student" therefore the principal willingly gives a TC and asks the child to leave b'coz the school wants a 100% results when the kids give their board exams otherwise the quality of the school goes down, we get a handful of good teachers who are really passionate about teaching the others are just hopping from one school to another looking for good pay scales and perks. THE WHOLE SYSTEM NEEDS TO BE REVAMPED SCHOOLS TEACHERS AND PARENTS

Chintan Girish Modi said...

Your blogpost reminds me of a poem I once wrote:
http://chintangirishmodi.wordpress.com/2009/05/12/off-the-mark/

Anil T said...

Yes Bharti, agreed. such teachers need to be caned! they are the ones responsible for the bookworm culture in our edu system.
anil

Mallik Kovuri's Blog said...

Nice note. I am currently a parent working through this stress. I have a 10th standard student and situation until recently was so that there was no assurance that he would at least pass the examination. My wife and tutors and several others held me accountable for his 'failure' (if he could yet be called). The main contention was the saying, 'Spare the rod, spoil the child'. I never held this opinion myself. I had always been insisting on the importance of learning the subject than focus on scoring high marks. I tried the counselling route 'all-along' with my child. I cannot say it was successful (like I said he had been in the verge of not-an-assured pass in examinations). But I still hold the opinion - the calling has to come from 'his-within'. Despite being so soft with him, I was shocked to know recently that he had been lying to me on several occasions. Time should tell, if I had been a 'bad parent' or a good-one!

Mallik

durgs said...

I so agree with you. I was the rebel of my house when depite scoring 81% in my HSC, I went for the Arts stream, coz I knew I loved the languages. (And I sucked at maths). My family was aghast. But my dad stood by me. He also stood by me when I chose this profession, despite my family acting crazy about it. And so far as children working in TV serials and reality shows is concerned... it's their age to play and learn, not earn. I would NEVER do this to my child.

Anonymous said...

Greets dude!

It is my first time here. I just wanted to say hi!

G. White said...

In my opinion, many children are born with a potential for depression and suicide. If they don't find the right triggers, they will carry on, till they become adults. But given the right triggers----educational pressures, parental expectations, improper food and sleep, media hype, body image hype, peer pressure, non-availablity of parents etc, they might take the ultimate step. We can only hope to reduce or eliminate these triggers, to avoid this. But in my opinion, all parents will say "Yes, but you know, what you say is true, but still, academics is everything in this country and children must work hard blah, blah, blah.... Acceptance and understanding are very major issues here, often coming only after the child has done something stupid.

send flowers to australia said...

Hey great stuff, thank you for sharing this useful information and i will let know my friends as well.

Canada flower shops said...

I really liked your article. Keep up the good work.

Anonymous said...

Sorry for my bad english. Thank you so much for your good post. Your post helped me in my college assignment, If you can provide me more details please email me.

Mark said...

With more and more users buying Android-based smart phones all over the world, it's no wonder that professionals adept in Android development are in high demand

best android apps

Just Friends said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Just Friends said...

Excellent material. Very insightful. Thanks For Sharing.

3D ultrasounds | 4d Ultrasounds

Unknown said...

Beautifully written as always! gogusestetigi